RAIDERS
OF THE LOST MAGIC.
Douglas
Daft, the new CEO of Coca-Cola chooses his words the way he chooses his business
alliances: very carefully. The business of Coke, he observes, is not about beverages, but
about "the idea of Coke, the magic of the brand." To traditional bottlers who
count their blessings in syrup sales, this is heresy. They've always sold 'refreshment',
not magic.
On closer inspection, this is not such a big departure. For over a
hundred years, the Atlanta company has revisited this business philosophy, that what they
sell is more than a secret formula that quenches thirst. In 1911, its tag line called it
a glass of liquid laughter. In 1953 it was Midsummer Magic. But
these are also tough times for the Atlanta company, and it would love to have a bit of the
magic spill over onto strategy. To work toward this magic formula, it phased out the
company that created the 'always' campaign (with its fragmented commercials) and instated
McCann-Erickson. Is there a message here? Let's not read too much into this about going
back to its roots. McCann is a very different kind of integrated marketing communications
company than what it was when it created the syrupy commercial about wanting to buy the
world a Coke.
Cokes search for the lost magic is really not about
re-instating the sizzle over substance. It has been determined by certain market factors
all lining up. Think of it as a company finding itself in the cross-hairs of a very
hostile market, suddenly needing to build its own missile programme.
The Reality: A broadening of the beverage segment.
Competition is tough, with non-cola beverages (iced tea, fruit juices, coffee and bottled
water) making inroads into what the beverage industry calls the share of
stomach. There are new weapons --and new territories at stake -- in the Cola Wars.
PepsiCo is seen to be on the offensive after it bought a new age non-carbonated brand
called SoBe last year. It then made the push to be the leader in this segment by acquiring
Quaker Oats last year. This gave it access to a powerful name of sports drinks, Gatorade.
Besides this, Quaker Oats has many of the snack foods that appear to market well alongside
Colas, as PepsiCo, and its sister company Frito-Lay already knows. Pepsi now has a long
line of salted snacks. Coca-Cola is lagging behind, but the tit-for-tat acquisition and
alliance spree is gathering momentum. Soon after Pepsi joined forces with megabrand coffee
company Starbucks, Coke acquired a small but well-known coffee brand, Planet Java. It will
go head to head with the Starbucks -Pepsi product, Frappucino. Another
non-cola competitor, Nestles Nesquick, will also be attacked with five new milk
based drinks. In March last year, Pepsi partnered with Yahoo! promising integrated online
marketing. Not to be outdone, Coke teamed up with an equally established online brand,
AOL, giving it enormous reach.
So can this momentum continue? More importantly how useful is it
from a strategic point of view? The market is changing so rapidly, and the channels of
communicating its message are so fragmented, that even a behemoth corporation like Coke
risks spreading itself too thin. Which is probably why the company has decided to enlist
help from those with macho marketing muscle. Ad agencies? Think again. The risky new
strategy is to partner with your competitors.
The Response: extend refreshment.
The seeds of this lie in Cokes long-standing alliance with Nestle since 1991. Even
though Nestle has beverage products, it partnered with it and set up the Coca-Cola Nestle
Refreshments Company. It teamed the strong Nestle trademarks with Cokes distribution
power; Nestles R&D with Cokes well-established infrastructure in many
countries. This grew into a more aggressive company, Beverage Partners
Worldwide. Today this practice is gaining popularity. (Chrysler, GM and Ford, once
fierce competitors formed an alliance in 1992 called USCAR, and more recently, formed a
B2B exchange called Covisint). In February Coke took a bold step announcing a strategic
alliance with Proctor and Gamble, owners of Sunny Delight. Coca-Cola will take advantage
of the packaged goods behemoth's branding experience. From Cokes perspective, it no
longer wants to dominate the fizzy red drink category.
The net is being cast wider. It wants to become "the global
leader in innovative snacks and nutritional beverages." Meaning Coke is no longer a
'beverage company'. It no longer wants to buy the world a Coke, but everything that goes
with it. |
On paper it is a great symbiotic relationship.
P&G have been shedding numerous non-core brands and could leverage Cokes vast
distribution system. Think of the scale. Coca-Cola owns 230 products in some 200
countries. P&G overshadow this with 300 brands in 140 countries!
The carbonated beverage segment is hardly growing, but despite
needing to maintain the lead on Pepsi, it cannot allow PepsiCo to get ahead in the snack
food category that it has been in for decades.
This was soon followed by a global partnership with Disney, giving
it access to a line up of yet another world-famous, and eternally relevant brand
properties: Mickey, Winnie and rest of the gang. To be sure, Disney is not a
competitor in the traditional sense. But it does compete for attention in a
market that is essentially youth, and fighting for first place at entertainment venues. So
creating a Disney line of soft drinks, and making that an inroad into childrens
lives, would get both brands the best real estate in anything from lunch boxes and screen
savers to clothing, music and movie tie-ins.
Ah! Those tie-ins. Coca-Colas next alliance was a coup d
gras when it chose Warner Brothers, the ramifications of which can only be described as
'magical'. Why? Warner Brothers won the rights for the movie version of Harry Potter, and
Coke has a shot to play in this coveted (movie-book) league. Then there is the
AOL-TimeWarner alliance itself that is almost as pervasive as Cokes distribution
network. Millions of people log on to this vast empire everyday to quench their thirst for
information and entertainment. If Coke does it right, if it continues to connect to a new
breed of customers across all these new channels, it might just re-invent the
magic it so dearly needs. Harry Potter and Mickey Mouse provide more than what
beverage people call 'mouth-feel'. It's magic. It's intangible. If only it can be
bottled!.
Lessons Learned:
Consumers want "open brands" that help them self-invent says Saatchi and Saatchi
thinker Myra Stark. For years, Coca-Cola was a closed brand, strictly defined by the
marketing wizards in Atlanta. But brands that only fill needs tend to remain static. They
assume the customers basic need (in Cokes case, refreshment) never change.
Cokes new alliances challenge that. Its new brands will fill environments, not
needs. The lesson for marketers is that in order to take branding from 'needs' to
'experience' you've got to rethink who your allies are. Sometimes you've got to break the
mould in order 'pry open' the brand. Observes Stark, "how can our brands help
consumers change? We know that brands must be grounded in a core of meaning...However, the
brand must be open and flexible enough to be relevant for consumers in a changing
world." Its not about teaching consumers. Its about learning
from them.
From a different perspective, its interesting to see what
another global megabrand in the online world is doing to make it robust, yet relevant
experience. Yahoo! has 24 portals in 12 languages. The Wall Street Journal reported that
the day-to-day running of Yahoo! portals for Hong Kong, India, Singapore and Taiwan are in
the hands of the local managers, reflecting each culture. In Taiwan, the music-news
section is important. In Singapore its Web-casting, and in India, cricket takes
prominence. It's as if the old-line company Coke learned an important lesson in global
strategy, long before the e-commerce rolled in. It's allowing customers (rather than the
copywriters) to define what a brand stands for. No longer will any agency be able to sell
a client on teaching the world to sing, or teaching the world to drink one
brand and one brand only. One-sight, One-sound, One sell, the old Coke mantra,
has been dispatched to the attic. The customer rules --with all his/her diversity,
idiosyncrasy and ethnic diversity. Synergy will have a state funeral. The genie is out of
the bottle. Maybe thats the real meaning of magic. |