Lies, damn lies, and email
In an information-rich
society, we have to be careful what we wish for. Remember a time
when we had to wait for news to trickle in? I was on a train to
Kandy with a group of friends in August 1977. The headline in the
Daily News that day was “Brezhnev responds to Carter’s call”.
Twenty-five years ago, news was something that had happened the
previous day --before the newspaper went to ‘bed’. When the train
pulled out of the Fort railway station, there was just no way we
could have known that a communal riot had broken out in the Matale
district that morning. Real-time information hadn't been invented.
Even rumour, the mother-of-all media-channels, didn't have a chance
to board that train.
It’s hard to
predict how different our lives can be with greater access to
information. Consider what happened to Dean Hachem, a Lebanese
immigrant to the United States. The Wall Street Journal reported how
Mr. Hachem, on September 12th 2001, was busy running a family-owned
Arab restaurant on the suburbs of Detroit. He returned to the
restaurant after picking up some American flags, only to find his
world had changed, thanks to e-mail. Someone, claiming to be the
mother-in-law of a doctor, had fired off an email to a friend. In
it, she had described a story she had heard from a nurse at a
hospital in the area. The nurse had been dining at the restaurant
the previous day, and had seen Arabs cheering while watching
television coverage of the terrorist attacks. Barely twenty-four
hours after this e-mail hit the wires, business at the restaurant
plummeted. That awful effect we mischievously call ‘word of mouse’
had set in.
On the other hand,
with so much spam today, some things just don’t get the attention we
expect. Sharon Watkins’ notorious e-mail took months to circulate.
Watkins was a senior Enron executive who wrote a long e-memo to her
boss. “We are under too much scrutiny,” she wrote talking about the
‘funny accounting' going on. It only surfaced when the company
imploded. Thousands of people lost their life savings as a
consequence, because Ken Lay, Enron's CEO, ignored it.
At other times,
the content of our inbound e-mail is so ludicrous that we dismiss it
instantly. A malicious e-mail circulating last year stated that
McDonald's in the USA would give their Saturday income to the
Israelis to fight Palestinians' terrorism. McDonald’s denied it. |
Those e-mails that move at
blazing speed are always rooted in the mythology of the time.
Cleverly crafted, they terrify us, anger us or tug at our
heartstrings. How many 'stories' did you seriously doubt, but pass
on to your network in the last month? The last year? In 1999, an
e-mail that made the rounds about Tom Hilfiger, stated that the
fashion designer had appeared on the Opra Winfrey show and insulted
Asians. It claimed that Tommy had said he wished Asian women would
not wear his clothing line because it devalued his brand. This was
at the beginning of the anti-globalization movement, when companies
were being blasted for inhuman wages, racism and environmental
disasters. The Hilfiger urban legend nicely fit. Was there a grain
of truth in the story? Nope. Opra hadn't even had Tommy on her show.
So it came as no
surprise when a flood of mischievous e-mails followed the World
Trade Center attacks last year. You heard the one about a woman
whose Afghani boyfriend had warned her to stay off airplanes on
September 11th? Most people did. Guess what? It was a hoax. And how
about the one about the photographer who unwittingly captured the
‘face of the devil’ in the thick, black cloud of smoke coming out of
the twin towers? Aha! That one was true. The freelance photographer
who took the pictures uploaded a series of digital pictures to the
Associated Press without glancing at the details. (You can see the
picture at
www.poynter.org/Terrorism/kenny7.htm)
‘Word of mouse’, as you can see, is hard at work.
Today e-mail hitches a
ride on something we all actively seek: news. But when it takes the
place of news –or rather, when it outpaces the delivery mechanisms
of modern media channels– we believe it at our own peril. People who
have played the stock market based on text messages received on a
cellphone know what it is to operate without a safety net.
It's easy to get
addicted to real-time information. But it arrives without the checks
and balances that existed in the twentieth century. SMS, like
e-mail, is changing the way we consume news, minus the filters. I’m
not against real-time news. Perhaps a text message on the ‘real’
situation –as opposed to a headline on the prolonged cold war
--might have changed the course of events for five of us on that
Kandy-bound train. The next morning, we were beaten up by a group of
thugs who 'mistook' us for... well, never mind. A broken nose always
heals. 'Word of mouse' brings mixed blessings as Tommy Hilfiger,
Dean Hachem and Muthiah Muralitharan will tell you. Which reminds
me, did you hear the one about how Murali was offered a job by Bill
Gates? Neither did I. I just made that up! So please don't e-mail it
to everyone in your address book! |